VINTAGE

Extended Stay Hotels Reviews: Top 10 Properties Travelers Love in 2025

1. Franklin Guesthouse – Best for Stylish, Apartment-Like Comfort

In trendy Greenpoint, this boutique property earns raves for its loft-style suites with full kitchens and in-unit laundry, making it a favorite for month-long stays.

  • Average Rating: 4.7/5 (800+ reviews on Expedia and TripAdvisor).
  • Key Amenities: Full kitchens with stainless appliances, free high-speed WiFi, on-site gym, pet-friendly options.
  • Weekly Rate Estimate (2025): $1,100 (monthly deals around $3,800).

Guest Reviews: “Spacious and clean—like a high-end apartment! The kitchen saved us on meals during our 3-week relocation.” – Recent TripAdvisor reviewer. Pros: Modern design, quiet location near McGolrick Park. Cons: Limited parking; book direct for upgrades.

Booking Tip: Use Expedia for flexible cancellations; aim for off-peak (Jan-Feb) to save 15-20%.

2. Pod Brooklyn – Top Budget-Friendly Micro-Stay in Williamsburg

Compact yet clever, Pod’s modular rooms with mini-fridges and shared kitchens appeal to solo travelers seeking affordability without sacrificing vibe.

  • Average Rating: 4.2/5 (2,500+ reviews on Yelp and TripAdvisor).
  • Key Amenities: Communal kitchens, 24/7 laundry, free WiFi, rooftop lounge.
  • Weekly Rate Estimate (2025): $850 (weekly promos at 10-15% off).

Guest Reviews: “Great value for a month in Brooklyn—clean, central, and the staff is super helpful with local tips.” – Yelp user, 2025. Pros: Eco-friendly features like low-water fixtures. Cons: Small rooms (150 sq ft); no full in-room cooking.

Booking Tip: Download the Pod app for loyalty perks; target spring for cherry blossom views near Domino Park.

3. Ace Hotel Brooklyn – Hipster Favorite for Creative Vibes in Boerum Hill

Ace’s artistic flair shines in rooms with record players and kitchenettes, ideal for extended creative residencies.

  • Average Rating: 4.6/5 (1,500+ reviews on Travelocity and Yelp).
  • Key Amenities: Kitchenettes, free WiFi, on-site cafe, bike rentals.
  • Weekly Rate Estimate (2025): $1,200.

Guest Reviews: “Exceptional service and design—felt like home during our 2-week stay. The rooftop events are a bonus!” – Travelocity reviewer. Pros: Vibrant community spaces. Cons: Higher rates; occasional noise from events.

Booking Tip: Join Ace’s newsletter for 2025 flash sales.

4. The Box House Hotel – Industrial-Chic Lofts in Greenpoint

Converted factory lofts offer expansive spaces with full kitchens, perfect for families on longer trips.

  • Average Rating: 4.5/5 (1,200+ reviews on Expedia).
  • Key Amenities: In-unit washer/dryer, free parking, rooftop with views.
  • Weekly Rate Estimate (2025): $1,050.

Guest Reviews: “Huge rooms with everything we needed for a month—loved the exposed brick!” – Expedia guest. Pros: Pet-friendly; rare free parking in NYC. Cons: No on-site dining.

Booking Tip: Direct bookings often include free upgrades.

5. Holiday Inn Express Brooklyn Sunset Park – Reliable Chain for Families

Spacious suites with fridges and breakfast included, in a diverse neighborhood.

  • Average Rating: 4.3/5 (1,100+ reviews on Yelp).
  • Key Amenities: Free breakfast, indoor pool, laundry.
  • Weekly Rate Estimate (2025): $950.

Guest Reviews: “Comfortable for our family of four—great location near parks and eats.” – Recent Yelp review. Pros: Kid-friendly perks. Cons: Farther from Manhattan.

Booking Tip: IHG rewards for points on extended stays.

6. Prospect Gardens Residence – Cozy, Homey Option in Prospect Heights

Apartment-style residences with kitchens, blending hotel service with residential feel.

  • Average Rating: 4.4/5 (900+ reviews on Yelp).
  • Key Amenities: Full kitchens, WiFi, nearby laundry.
  • Weekly Rate Estimate (2025): $900.

Guest Reviews: “Felt like our own Brooklyn pad—quiet and convenient to Prospect Park.” – Yelp user. Pros: Residential vibe. Cons: Limited hotel amenities.

Booking Tip: Check for monthly specials via direct site.

7. Hampton Inn Brooklyn Downtown – Business-Ready with Views

Ergonomic workspaces and kitchenettes in a central downtown spot.

  • Average Rating: 4.5/5 (1,300+ reviews on TripAdvisor).
  • Key Amenities: Free WiFi, fitness center, evening receptions.
  • Weekly Rate Estimate (2025): $1,000.

Guest Reviews: “Perfect for remote work—strong WiFi and comfy beds for our 10-day stay.” – TripAdvisor. Pros: Reliable Hilton brand. Cons: Books up quickly.

Booking Tip: Hilton Honors for discounts.

8. Tru by Hilton Brooklyn Williamsburg – Fun, Affordable for Young Pros

Colorful rooms with kitchenettes and social lounges.

  • Average Rating: 4.4/5 (900+ reviews on Travelocity).
  • Key Amenities: Free breakfast, game rooms, WiFi.
  • Weekly Rate Estimate (2025): $850.

Guest Reviews: “Vibrant and budget-friendly—ideal for our group extended trip.” – Travelocity. Pros: Social atmosphere. Cons: Elevator waits during peaks.

Booking Tip: Bundle with ferry passes.

9. Aloft New York Brooklyn – Tech-Savvy in Downtown

Modern suites with plug-and-play tech and full kitchens.

  • Average Rating: 4.4/5 (900+ reviews on Expedia).
  • Key Amenities: Bar, fitness studio, pet-friendly.
  • Weekly Rate Estimate (2025): $1,100.

Guest Reviews: “Great WiFi for work; loved the DUMBO location for evenings out.” – Expedia. Pros: Fun energy. Cons: Weekend crowds.

Booking Tip: Marriott Bonvoy perks.

10. Super 8 by Wyndham Brooklyn Park Slope – Ultra-Budget in Family Area

Basic kitchenettes in a quiet, park-adjacent spot.

  • Average Rating: 3.8/5 (700+ reviews on Yelp).
  • Key Amenities: Free breakfast, laundry.
  • Weekly Rate Estimate (2025): $650.

Guest Reviews: “Cheap and cheerful for a long stay—close to everything in Park Slope.” – Yelp. Pros: Wallet-friendly. Cons: Basic finishes.

Booking Tip: Wyndham Rewards for free nights.

Quick Comparison Table: Top Extended Stay Hotels in Brooklyn NY 2025

RankHotel NameNeighborhoodWeekly RateRatingKitchen?Pet-Friendly?
1Franklin GuesthouseGreenpoint$1,1004.7FullYes
2Pod BrooklynWilliamsburg$8504.2MiniYes
3Ace Hotel BrooklynBoerum Hill$1,2004.6KitchenetteYes
4The Box House HotelGreenpoint$1,0504.5FullYes
5Holiday Inn ExpressSunset Park$9504.3FullYes
6Prospect Gardens ResidenceProspect Heights$9004.4FullNo
7Hampton InnDowntown$1,0004.5KitchenetteYes
8Tru by HiltonWilliamsburg$8504.4KitchenetteYes
9Aloft New YorkDowntown$1,1004.4FullYes
10Super 8Park Slope$6503.8MiniNo

FAQs

What makes a great extended stay hotel based on 2025 reviews?

High ratings prioritize kitchens for self-catering, reliable WiFi for work, and flexible rates—saving 20%+ on weekly bookings.

Are there pet-friendly options in Brooklyn?

Yes, like Franklin Guesthouse and Pod Brooklyn (fees $25-50/night); check policies for breeds.

How have rates changed from 2024?

Slight 5-10% increase due to demand, but apps like HotelTonight offer deals.

Best for families?

Holiday Inn Express or Prospect Gardens, with space and park access praised in reviews.

Back to top button